Strong, David

• Name	Strong, David  [1]
  	20200525HAv- Elizabeth Olmstead McBride?/Chautauqua County, NY Genealogy Yesterday · 24 May 2020 Another photo from the collection of Lillian McCullough Olmstead. It is labeled Hattie and Minnie Walkup. I believe their parents were Charles Walkup and Caroline Strong. Caroline was the daughter of David Strong and his first wife Mahala Clark, and a half sister to my great grandmother Mahala Strong Olmstead. Charles and Caroline had three daughters; - Miranda born in 1856, - Ella born in 1858, and - Hattie born in 1870. Now, in this photo Hattie and Minnie look to be about the same age. I am not sure who Minnie is. Is it a nickname for Miranda? But Miranda and Hattie are 12 years apart in age. The 1870 census has Minnie as 13 y.o., Ella as 12 y.o., and Hattie as 4 months old. So, Minnie is Miranda. The 1880 census has - Hattie as 10 and her sister - Minnie as 23. They are the only 2 children listed with their parents. Ella, who would be 22 is not listed, assume she is married. - Yes, she married in 1880 and is listed with her husband F.J. Eddy. Hmmm, no way are the two girls in this photo 12-13 years apart. Four hours of investigation later, I think the girls are Miranda, aka Minnie, and Ella. And when the photo was labeled many years later, probably by Lillian McCullough Olmstead, she got the names confused so rather than being Hattie and Minnie, they are Minnie and Ella. 1313 4 Comments 1 Share Like Comments Elizabeth Olmstead McBride I should add, they lived in the Charlotte/Sinclairville area. Like · Reply · 1d Candy Welsh-Payne I'm noticing that the young lady on th left is seated but with the flurry of fabric its not so noticeable. That's what make the two girls appear the same size. Lovely pic!! Like · Reply · 1d Elizabeth Olmstead McBride Yes, but no way are they 12 years apart in age. Like · Reply · 23h Stephen West Wonderful picture! Like · Reply · 1d
  Gender	Male
  Person ID	I79286	WETZEL-SPRING

  
  

  Family 1	Clark, Mahala
  Marriage	David's 1st wife was Mahala Clark  [1]
  	20200525HAv- Elizabeth Olmstead McBride?/Chautauqua County, NY Genealogy Yesterday · 24 May 2020 Another photo from the collection of Lillian McCullough Olmstead. It is labeled Hattie and Minnie Walkup. I believe their parents were Charles Walkup and Caroline Strong. Caroline was the daughter of David Strong and his first wife Mahala Clark, and a half sister to my great grandmother Mahala Strong Olmstead. Charles and Caroline had three daughters; - Miranda born in 1856, - Ella born in 1858, and - Hattie born in 1870. Now, in this photo Hattie and Minnie look to be about the same age. I am not sure who Minnie is. Is it a nickname for Miranda? But Miranda and Hattie are 12 years apart in age. The 1870 census has Minnie as 13 y.o., Ella as 12 y.o., and Hattie as 4 months old. So, Minnie is Miranda. The 1880 census has - Hattie as 10 and her sister - Minnie as 23. They are the only 2 children listed with their parents. Ella, who would be 22 is not listed, assume she is married. - Yes, she married in 1880 and is listed with her husband F.J. Eddy. Hmmm, no way are the two girls in this photo 12-13 years apart. Four hours of investigation later, I think the girls are Miranda, aka Minnie, and Ella. And when the photo was labeled many years later, probably by Lillian McCullough Olmstead, she got the names confused so rather than being Hattie and Minnie, they are Minnie and Ella. 1313 4 Comments 1 Share Like Comments Elizabeth Olmstead McBride I should add, they lived in the Charlotte/Sinclairville area. Like · Reply · 1d Candy Welsh-Payne I'm noticing that the young lady on th left is seated but with the flurry of fabric its not so noticeable. That's what make the two girls appear the same size. Lovely pic!! Like · Reply · 1d Elizabeth Olmstead McBride Yes, but no way are they 12 years apart in age. Like · Reply · 23h Stephen West Wonderful picture! Like · Reply · 1d
  Children	1. Strong, Caroline  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
  Family ID	F50352	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

  
  

  Family 2	Strong, mrs2 David
  Marriage	Caroline was half-sister to Eliz Olmstead McBride'  [1]
  	20200525HAv- Elizabeth Olmstead McBride?/Chautauqua County, NY Genealogy Yesterday · 24 May 2020 Another photo from the collection of Lillian McCullough Olmstead. It is labeled Hattie and Minnie Walkup. I believe their parents were Charles Walkup and Caroline Strong. Caroline was the daughter of David Strong and his first wife Mahala Clark, and a half sister to my great grandmother Mahala Strong Olmstead. Charles and Caroline had three daughters; - Miranda born in 1856, - Ella born in 1858, and - Hattie born in 1870. Now, in this photo Hattie and Minnie look to be about the same age. I am not sure who Minnie is. Is it a nickname for Miranda? But Miranda and Hattie are 12 years apart in age. The 1870 census has Minnie as 13 y.o., Ella as 12 y.o., and Hattie as 4 months old. So, Minnie is Miranda. The 1880 census has - Hattie as 10 and her sister - Minnie as 23. They are the only 2 children listed with their parents. Ella, who would be 22 is not listed, assume she is married. - Yes, she married in 1880 and is listed with her husband F.J. Eddy. Hmmm, no way are the two girls in this photo 12-13 years apart. Four hours of investigation later, I think the girls are Miranda, aka Minnie, and Ella. And when the photo was labeled many years later, probably by Lillian McCullough Olmstead, she got the names confused so rather than being Hattie and Minnie, they are Minnie and Ella. 1313 4 Comments 1 Share Like Comments Elizabeth Olmstead McBride I should add, they lived in the Charlotte/Sinclairville area. Like · Reply · 1d Candy Welsh-Payne I'm noticing that the young lady on th left is seated but with the flurry of fabric its not so noticeable. That's what make the two girls appear the same size. Lovely pic!! Like · Reply · 1d Elizabeth Olmstead McBride Yes, but no way are they 12 years apart in age. Like · Reply · 23h Stephen West Wonderful picture! Like · Reply · 1d
  Children	1. Strong, Mahala  [Father: natural]  [Mother: natural]
  Family ID	F50353	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart

  
  

• Sources

  [S2422] FaceBook Chautauqua Co Genealogy, from the collection of Lillian McCullough Olmstead, Hattie (or Ella) & Minnie (or Minnie & Ella) Walkup.Elizabeth Olmstead McBride · 24 May 2020. Minnie and Ella Walkup ( 20200525HAv- 20200525HAv- Elizabeth Olmstead McBride?/Chautauqua County, NY Genealogy Yesterday · 24 May 2020 Another photo from the collection of Lillian McCullough Olmstead. It is labeled Hattie and Minnie Walkup. I believe their parents were Charles Walkup and Caroline Strong. Caroline was the daughter of David Strong and his first wife Mahala Clark, and a half sister to my great grandmother Mahala Strong Olmstead. Charles and Caroline had three daughters; - Miranda born in 1856, - Ella born in 1858, and - Hattie born in 1870. Now, in this photo Hattie and Minnie look to be about the same age. I am not sure who Minnie is. Is it a nickname for Miranda? But Miranda and Hattie are 12 years apart in age. The 1870 census has Minnie as 13 y.o., Ella as 12 y.o., and Hattie as 4 months old. So, Minnie is Miranda. The 1880 census has - Hattie as 10 and her sister - Minnie as 23. They are the only 2 children listed with their parents. Ella, who would be 22 is not listed, assume she is married. - Yes, she married in 1880 and is listed with her husband F.J. Eddy. Hmmm, no way are the two girls in this photo 12-13 years apart. Four hours of investigation later, I think the girls are Miranda, aka Minnie, and Ella. And when the photo was labeled many years later, probably by Lillian McCullough Olmstead, she got the names confused so rather than being Hattie and Minnie, they are Minnie and Ella. 1313 4 Comments 1 Share Like Comments Elizabeth Olmstead McBride I should add, they lived in the Charlotte/Sinclairville area. Like · Reply · 1d Candy Welsh-Payne I'm noticing that the young lady on th left is seated but with the flurry of fabric its not so noticeable. That's what make the two girls appear the same size. Lovely pic!! Like · Reply · 1d Elizabeth Olmstead McBride Yes, but no way are they 12 years apart in age. Like · Reply · 23h Stephen West Wonderful picture! Like · Reply · 1d Walkup, Minnie & Ella sibs FB200524Chau 20200525HAv- Elizabeth Olmstead McBride?Chautauqua County, NY Genealogy Yesterday · 24 May 2020 Another photo from the collection of Lillian McCullough Olmstead. It is labeled Hattie and Minnie Walkup. I believe their parents were Charles Walkup and Caroline Strong. Caroline was the daughter of David Strong and his first wife Mahala Clark, and…

  
  

TEST MARKER

TNG ID: I79286